Why Google’s Nexus One is No Threat to iPhone

After eWeek revealed its top 10 reasons why no one should buy the upcoming Nexus One, it almost made us sick to the point of not listening to anyone skeptical enough to question the Google phone. However, ABC’s latest editorial changed that thinking for us. Sure, we are just as excited about the Nexus One as many of you are, but a healthy dose of skepticism has never hurt anyone. If anything, it adds a much needed balance to all the hype that’s been around the phone.

The article isn’t saying why the Nexus One will fail, it’s looking at the phone from Apple’s perspective in relation to the iPhone and why it’s too much of a competitor. It says, “The only other ways to catch Apple right now is to either price bomb the iPhone with a super cheap, super powerful smart phone – easier said than done, especially since you’re giving away all of your profits – or come out with your own, revolutionary, new design. But nobody’s been able to end run Apple yet; revolutionary new design being what that company does better than anybody.”

Now that’s an opinion worth reading. Well thought out and clearly put. In essence, Google could’ve had the opportunity to come up with something as unique as the iPhone in 2007, but it failed to really change the mobile industry. Another way of looking at it is that Google may not be innovative with the user interface or the hardware, but it’s definitely going to eventually roll out services that will make their devices all the better. While Apple is concentrating on its hardware, user interface, OS and platform, Google is solely focused on the Web. Different strategies for different experiences. We’re still too early in the mobile game and declaring a winner now would be an epic mistake.

Tagged as: , ,

Other related articles:

  • Fammy
    @Gundeep Hora

    All smart phones are heavy, and battery life is pathetic.
    How can people spend that amount of money on them is beyond me.
  • @Fammy: Heavy in relation to what? I can understand if you were calling a 6lb laptop heavy because carrying around a gadget like that for any period of time is a pain, but to call a smartphone, which is essentially a mini-computer in your pocket, heavy is outrageous. Battery life is definitely pathetic, I agree. I'm a ridiculously heavy smartphone user, and I can drain the battery out in less than 6 hours, sometimes earlier depending on my schedule, but I can also plug it in and the device is fully recharged in an hour or so. With the amount of benefits it offers, I can live with carrying a charger with me and plugging it in anytime I get a chance. Of course I have access to my laptop for a good majority of the day, so I'm not completely dependent on the phone.

    People get so excited and spend so much money on them because of their value proposition. They are not just tools for business executives anymore. They let you entertain yourself (movies, music and games) and work hand-in-hand simultaneously (email, phone calls etc.). Not to mention they are great for spontaneous plans for things like movie timings, restaurant reviews, destinations to see, directions etc. You know, a few years ago, there was no way I could go on a vacation without my laptop, but today, I can actually see myself leaving behind my laptop and exclusively using my phone for everything that I need while on vacation. You'd be nuts not to fall in love with mobile technology.
  • Fammy
    Both (iphone and nexus) are heavy (130g +) phones. Once they manage to make the weight go bellow the 100g and battery life last a lot longer I will consider it for daily usage. Right now, they don't make a much sense to me. Kids might like it though.
  • @Fammy: You think the iPhone 3GS or the Nexus One are heavy devices? Seriously? There's no reason not to buy either one because of weight. This is the first time I'm hearing anyone not buying latest mobile technology because they are too heavy. I don't know how the battery life is related to weight. I doubt it is. If anything, I'd much rather have my phones be heavy because they feel rock solid in my hand and not cheap plastic that will break any second.
  • Bobbo
    That ABC article was laughable at best, it's crazy how the iSheep go nuts everytime their princess phone gets one-upped. The uniformed and terminally stupid just don't get it. The Nexus One is not an iPhone killer, neither is the Droid, the G1, the myTouch, the HTC Hero, etc. Android is the iPhone killer. Google is going to steamroll Apple the same way Microsoft did in the 80's. The iPhone will be a niche player, always hanging on to its fanboys. But the public will go to Android and it's plethora of phones. Google is too fast, too smart and too cutting edge for a one man show like Apple. Sorry kids, the end is coming.
  • @Bobbo: I wouldn't say the ABC article was a joke. Yes, you're right about Android to an extent. However, keep in mind that companies that are behind Android are getting worried. Android will start to become an everyday OS if Google isn't careful with distribution and making sure Android plays nice with all handsets. It's all about controlling the experience. Apple does it, maybe to the point of overdoing it at times, but it has paid off for them. Everything is tied to delivering user experience. Google is trying to take a fragmented Web approach to their OS and user experience will suffer long-term.
blog comments powered by Disqus